Sculpting on both are fantastic. Little details like being able to see the hem in the cuff of Kirks pants and Picards rank pips being sculpted are awesome. There is in a slight texture to the clothing. Kirks face is spot on and Picards is really good in hand. I think the pics online look off because the paint on Picards face is very subtle.
These are a little light on accessories but the ones the come with ar nicely done, with the exception of Kirks phaser. It is way to big. So fish out one of your old DST/AA phasers and you will be all set.
They have actual stands with a peg that fits in the bottom of the right foot. Nothing fancy but they do the trick to keep them upright. However they do stand on their own just fine.
The paint is a lot better than I have seen on a lot of McFarlanes figures in the past. It looks like the heads are actually molded in flesh tone with subtle shading on top. My Picard came out perfect but my Kirk however came with the left eye and eyebrow a little out of place. It wasn't bad but it made him look like he was looking to the left. I fixed it but this is one of those things that will make you probably want to find them in store to look them over first.
Now about the "size/scale" difference. There isn't actually a difference in scale, they just made either Picard to tall or Kirk to short. The hands can be swapped easily and the heads look like they should be able to be swapped easily too. Those are all the same size. After looking them over it looks like they made Picards torso a bit to long. Unfortunately this happens in a lot of different figure lines and has happened in McFarlanes Walking Dead line even between different versions of the same character over the years. You can buy three different versions of Rick Grimes and each one will be a different height. These at least fit together scale wise, unlike DST's version of TOS and TNG. Or even the variations between TNG figures themselves.I'm sure they will eventually do another Picard and he will most like be a different height. Lol.
My biggest concerns are the wrist pegs. They seem a little thin and I'm afraid I might brake one off while swapping hands. So take it easy.
Overall these are great figures. I see them being a huge step up from DST and AA. Kind of like how DST/AA was a huge step above Playmates. I really hope we get many more figures for years to come. I can't wait to see what they do with the aliens of a Trek.